Advancements in accurate digitization of 3D objects through photogrammetry are ongoing in the cultural heritage space, for the purposes of digital archival and worldwide access. This paper outlines and documents several user-driven enhancements to the photogrammetry pipeline to improve the fidelity of digitizations. In particular, we introduce a new platform for capturing empirically-based specularity of 3D models called Kintsugi 3D, and visually compare traditional photogrammetry results with this new technique. Kintsugi 3D is a free and open-source package that features, among other things, the ability to generate a set of textures for a 3D model, including normal and specularity maps, based empirically on ground-truth observations from a flash-on-camera image set. It is hoped that the ongoing development of Kintsugi 3D will improve public access for institutions with an interest in sharing high-fidelity photogrammetry.