Naturalness is a complex appearance attribute that is dependent on multiple visual appearance attributes like color, gloss, roughness, and their interaction. It impacts the perceived quality of an object and should therefore be reproduced correctly. In recent years, the use of color 3D printing technology has seen considerable growth in different fields like cultural heritage, medical, entertainment, and fashion for producing 3D objects with the correct appearance. This paper investigates the reproduction of naturalness attribute using a color 3D printing technology and the naturalness perception of the 3D printed objects. Results indicate that naturalness perception of 3D printed objects is highly subjective but is found to be objectively dependent mainly on a printed object’s surface elevation and roughness.