With the proliferation of smartphones and social networking services, the opportunities for individuals to take photographs have increased exponentially. In a previous study, the perceived gloss of an object was reduced by its representing as a digital image and compared with a real object. It is also known that image editing, such as lossy image compression, can reduce the glossiness of an image. Therefore, the glossiness of real objects may be easily changed in digital images; thus, a method for appropriately editing the gloss in digital images is required for post-processing. In this study, we propose a gloss appearance editing method for various material objects in a single digital image. The proposed method consists of three steps: color space conversion, gloss detection, and gloss editing. The relationship between the proposed method and the respective reflection models of inhomogeneous objects, metallic objects, and translucent objects was analyzed. Consequently, we determined that the gloss editing of the proposed method is equivalent to editing the specular reflection component of an inhomogeneous object, the grazing reflection component of a metallic object, and the specular reflection component of a translucent object. We applied the proposed method to test images including objects of various materials and confirmed its effectiveness through a subjective evaluation by visual inspection and an objective evaluation using image statistics.