Back to articles
Volume: 56 | Article ID: art00006
MaxRGB Reconsidered
  DOI :  10.2352/J.ImagingSci.Technol.2012.56.2.020501  Published OnlineMarch 2012

The poor performance of the MaxRGB illumination-estimation method is often used in the literature as a foil when promoting some new illumination-estimation method. However, MaxRGB has usually been tested on images of only 8-bits per channel, where clipping of high radiances is likely to have occurred. The question arises as to whether the method itself is inadequate, or rather whether it has simply been tested on data of inadequate dynamic range or with inadequate preprocessing. In particular, is MaxRGB's underlying assumption that there is a white or white-equivalent surface present in every scene too strong? This question is explored here in two ways. The first avenue of investigation is based on a new database of 105 sets of multiple-exposure images. High-dynamic range images are constructed from these sets as well. The color of the scene illumination is determined by taking an extra image of the scene containing four Gretag Macbeth mini-Colorcheckers placed at an angle to one another. MaxRGB is found to perform surprisingly well when tested on either the multiple-exposure or the high-dynamic range images. The second avenue of investigation is to add some simple preprocessing to the basic MaxRGB algorithm. By removing clipped pixels followed by median filtering, MaxRGB also performs better than previously reported when tested on test images of common color constancy test sets, specifically the Simon Fraser University 321-image indoor set. In particular, the Wilcoxon signed-rank test indicates that MaxRGB outperforms the most recent bright-pixel variant of color by correlation on the 321 set. MaxRGB is also competitive against the recent Edge-Based algorithm and significantly better than the computationally intensive Bayesian method on the Grayball set and the Colorchecker set. Overall, the results presented demonstrate that MaxRGB is far more effective than it has been reputed to be.

Subject Areas :
Views 24
Downloads 0
 articleview.views 24
 articleview.downloads 0
  Cite this article 

Lilong Shi, Brian Funt, "MaxRGB Reconsideredin Journal of Imaging Science and Technology,  2012,  pp 20501-1 - 20501-10,

 Copy citation
  Copyright statement 
Copyright © Society for Imaging Science and Technology 2012
  Login or subscribe to view the content